Best Italian Restaurants in Aruba 2026: 5 Top Picks

Italian cooking has deep roots in Aruba — handmade pasta, wood-fired pizza, and serious Italian wine lists turn up across the island. Here are the 5 Italian restaurants on Aruba worth booking.

The 5 best Italian restaurants in Aruba

1. Lucca Trattoria — handmade pasta on Palm Beach

Lucca brings genuine Italian to Palm Beach — handmade pasta, proper pizza, and an Italian-curated wine list. Solid choice if you want classic Italian on the resort strip.

2. Terrazza Italiana — wood-fired pizza, Eagle Beach

Proper Italian cooking from Eagle Beach — handmade pasta, wood-fired pizza, and an Italian wine list. A bit quieter than Palm Beach options.

3. Faro Blanco — Italian at the California Lighthouse

Italian dining inside the original lighthouse keeper’s stone house at the California Lighthouse on Aruba’s northwestern tip. Famous for sunset terrace seating and a 100+ bottle wine list spanning Italy, France, and Argentina.

4. Quinta del Carmen — colonial mansion, Bubali

Set in a restored 1918 mansion, Quinta del Carmen blends Italian-influenced fine dining with a Dutch-Caribbean menu. Romantic garden seating; great for special occasions.

5. Anno 1877 — historic Oranjestad fine dining

Anno 1877 occupies a historic building in Oranjestad, blending Italian and Mediterranean influences with a refined fine-dining experience.

Picking the right Italian for your trip

For resort-strip convenience, Lucca on Palm Beach. For quieter Eagle Beach dining, Terrazza Italiana. For iconic sunset views, Faro Blanco at the lighthouse. For romance, Quinta del Carmen’s garden. For a refined Oranjestad fine-dining night, Anno 1877.